Matter of E-Z- Immigration Ruling: What It Means for Convention Against Torture Protection
The U.S. immigration system just got tougher for people seeking protection from torture. In a recent decision known as Matter of E-Z-, the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) raised the standard for proving that deportation would likely result in torture. This ruling could make it significantly more difficult for immigrants to win protection under the Convention Against Torture (CAT).
At Rozas, we’re here to break down what this decision means, how it impacts immigrants, and why having an experienced immigration attorney is now more important than ever.
What Is the Matter of E-Z- Immigration Ruling?
In June 2025, the BIA issued a decision in the case Matter of E-Z- that overturned an immigration judge’s (IJ) ruling granting CAT protection to a man from Russia. The man argued he would likely be tortured if deported, due to his support for Ukraine. After hearing testimony and reviewing evidence, the immigration judge ruled in his favor.
However, the BIA reversed the immigration judge’s decision, stating that the evidence presented was too speculative and not concrete enough to meet the high standard required for CAT protection. This marks a significant shift in how appeals courts treat the factual findings of immigration judges, signaling a higher burden of proof for applicants.
Why This Case Matters
The decision underscores two important trends:
- The BIA is now more willing to overrule immigration judges on fact-based findings.
- Immigrants claiming likely torture face a tougher path to proving their claims.
If you’re facing deportation and fear torture, it’s crucial to understand these changes and build a stronger, evidence-backed case.
How Does CAT Protection Work in Immigration Cases?
The Convention Against Torture (CAT) is an international treaty the U.S. honors, prohibiting deportation of someone to a country where they are more likely than not to face torture. Unlike asylum, CAT protection does not depend on persecution for reasons like religion, race, or political opinion—it solely focuses on the likelihood of torture.
To qualify for CAT protection, you must prove:
- That it is more likely than not you will be tortured if removed.
- The torture would be inflicted by or with the consent of a public official.
- The evidence is specific and credible, not speculative.
The Matter of E-Z- ruling raises the bar on what counts as "specific and credible," making it harder to meet this standard.
Why the Matter of E-Z- Ruling Is Troubling
Before this ruling, immigration judges’ findings on evidence and credibility carried significant weight. In Matter of E-Z-, the immigration judge heard the testimony, reviewed documents, and ruled in favor of the applicant. But the BIA decided to second-guess the immigration judge, dismissing the evidence as insufficient.
This sets a concerning precedent:
- Judges’ first-hand assessments of evidence may carry less influence.
- Applicants may now need even more documentation and corroboration.
- Even credible, fact-based claims could be deemed "too speculative."
This trend could deter applicants from seeking protection and could leave vulnerable individuals unprotected.
What Should You Do Now?
If you fear torture or other harm in your home country, don’t let this ruling stop you from seeking help, but understand that the bar is now higher. An experienced immigration attorney can help you:
- Gather detailed, credible evidence to support your claim.
- Prepare expert testimony or country condition reports.
- Anticipate and address challenges under the stricter standard.
At Rozas, we have helped countless clients navigate the complex U.S. immigration system and fight for their right to stay safe. Contact us today for a Free Consultation to discuss your case.
You Don’t Have to Face This Alone
The Matter of E-Z- immigration ruling has raised the stakes for anyone seeking Convention Against Torture protection in immigration cases. But with the right legal team, you still have a chance to fight for your future.
Don’t let a complex legal system or harsh new rulings stand in your way. Call Rozas today for a confidential consultation and let us help you build the strongest possible case.
Contact us now to get started today!
If you'd like to receive email updates about new immigration changes, click here to subscribe to our newsletter.
.svg)
.svg)